Closed
Labels
designChanges what the model can express (a shape decision)Changes what the model can express (a shape decision)question
Milestone
Description
A credential clause in brackets reads as a suffix (rules/S13, the bracket escape). A credential written joined, as MD/PhD or MD-PhD, reads as a nickname inside the brackets, though suffix_as_written reads the same joined form as a suffix outside them (rules/S12):
| Input | master | If set_apart_kind asks suffix_as_written |
|---|---|---|
John Smith (MD/PhD) |
nickname MD/PhD |
suffix MD/PhD |
John (MD/PhD) Smith |
nickname | suffix |
John Smith (MD-PhD) |
nickname | suffix |
This moves 3 names on a 22-name grid and 0 of the 6,939 snapshot names (#1084).
- Design question:
set_apart_kindkeeps its own suffix test because S13 reads amemberflag thatsuffix_as_writtendoesn't return. Asking the shared predicate would also take in the separate dotted-member test, whose kept-comma strip adds asuffix-or-nicknamereport toJohn (M.A,) Smith,John (M.A.,) Smithand(M.A,), PhD. - Proposed rule shape (an Except for S13):
- When: a bracketed clause holds one word that S12 reads as a joined credential.
- Then: it is the suffix, as its split spelling is.
- Because: a slash or hyphen between listed credentials is a way of writing the list, not a nickname.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
designChanges what the model can express (a shape decision)Changes what the model can express (a shape decision)question
Activity
AGENTS.md: run the 3.15 suite in an environment of its own (#1099)
Read a joined credential in brackets as its words written apart (#1088)…
AGENTS.md: keep a credential listed whole with its joiner in a chunk …
Read a member of the ambiguous class beside a credential as a credent…