Skip to content

Should John Smith (M.A/PhD) read suffix M.A/PhD, as John Smith (M.A, PhD) does? #1138

Closed

Description

@derek73

rules/S3 (credentials written in joined chunks) reads a word joined by / or - as a suffix when every chunk counts as a suffix as written. A dotted member of the ambiguous class without its final period (M.A) is no suffix as written, so a joined word holding it is refused, though rules/S13 (a bracketed member settled by its writing) reads the same member as a credential when its words are written apart in brackets after the name. Split from #1103, whose fix left this gap open.

Measured 2026-11-06 on the #1103 branch:

Input Reads Its words written apart
John Smith (M.A/PhD) nickname M.A/PhD (M.A, PhD): suffix M.A, PhD
John (M.A/PhD) Smith nickname, no report (M.A, PhD): nickname, reports suffix-or-nickname
John Smith M.A/PhD middle Smith, family M.A/PhD M.A, PhD: family M.A, suffix PhD, reports suffix-or-name
John Smith M.A./PhD suffix M.A./PhD (the member with its final period counts)

Proposed rule shape (an amendment to S3, or to S13):

How often it is written: not yet measured (NPPES's slash spellings and ClinicalTrials.gov officials are the places to count).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions