pm-dispatch: a lane without the contract-review tier knocks a review seat, never triage — one route in contract-review.md, and post-stamped refuses the triage knock

.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/contract-review.md

@@ -18,8 +18,11 @@
 - 已发布面以包的 `exports` 映射为准:从入口类型图不可达、且 `exports` 不可寻址的 `.d.ts` 是
   出货字节,⛔ 不是已发布接受集,改它不触发 `Clause-②: yes`;legacy node10 深引用在契约之外。
 - 四面皆不碰 ⇒ CI 加席位自读 ⛔ 不起第二个 agent;谁跑 = 派发席,档经子代理或卡线程取。
-- 取档被配额拒(HTTP 429)⇒ ⛔ 不降档,留标记落交接行,点复核席,无则兄弟席:
+- 送审路由只住此处:车道能取 `CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER` 才自审;取不到(账号够不到、配额拒 429、
+  维护者限配)⇒ ⛔ 不降档 ⛔ 非分诊,落交接行并同笔敲在座复核席 `Request: contract-review`;
+  无复核席在座改点能取该档的兄弟席,皆无则挂等复核标记留欠审表待 (a)(b)(c)。交接行:
 - `Contract-review-handoff: <review#N|domain:<lane>#N> — CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER unavailable (<HTTP status / error>, <UTC time>) · head <sha>`
+- 「立 skills 卡，把契约复审的路由直接改成 review 座位」「没有 fable 时，找 review 座位」(卡33157)
 - 欠审 PR(含 draft)现 head 无记录无活认领且 (a)(b)(c) 之一 ⇒ 复核席先接,车道次之,⛔ 非分诊
 - (a) 交接行点名现 head 或带等复核标记,同轮由所点席接;(b) 现 head 已等满一轮(约 60 分钟);
 - (c) 车道收班或离总表:欠审入交班简报待下席或复核席;清单 `scripts/pm/check-owed-reviews.mjs`。

.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/dispatch-runbook.md

@@ -217,6 +217,7 @@
 - 例:`screen-input-contract.ts` 的 grep 命中「ruling A′」,裁决区写 `A′ · 5651909056` 与原句:
   「a non-number for a numeric field is refused, never silently passed」;路线随之为拒收(A′)。
 - 原令「有限数字串转数字」与之相左,应派发前送复核;栅栏点名 A′ 的 spec 散文在范围。
+- 派发令带送审路由:dev 交回点名欠审不自敲;席照 contract-review.md 自审或送复核席,⛔ 非分诊
 - 新 changeset 文件名用 `<issue>-<slug>.md`,⛔ 不用随机词对名。
 - same-day churn 行:派发时 `git log origin/main --oneline -20 -- <paths>` 见当天合并即加一行。
 - 该行原文:基于合并后的代码工作,issue 引用的片段可能已变,先核对当前 main。

.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/review.md

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@
 
 ## 路由
 
-- 车道 `Request: contract-review` 敲任一复核席信箱,空闲者接;无复核席在座敲兄弟席,⛔ 非分诊
+- 车道何时送审、敲谁只住 contract-review.md 送审路由行;敲任一复核席信箱,空闲者接
 - 互斥 = 既有 `Contract-review-claim:` 行:同 head 先贴者持有,复核席之间同此;后者撤回弃产出。
 - 欠审表 `check-owed-reviews.mjs` 先给复核席;车道只在无复核席在座或 (b) 后再一轮无认领才接
 - delta 复审归原复核者;复核席下班留下旧记录 ⇒ 下一复核席接 delta,交接行点名它。

scripts/pm/check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs

@@ -446,7 +446,14 @@ export const CEILINGS = new Map([
   // may not change, and the `Premise:` claim line. Measured delta +4; the section
   // heading was renamed in place. Not a CROSS_FILE_MOVES destination, so no
   // `ruledRaises` record applies. Landed count, headroom 0, same convention.
-  ['.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/dispatch-runbook.md', 245],
+  // Raised 245 → 246 by the contract-review route (maintainer, 2026-11-13, in the
+  // triage seat's session, verbatim: 「立 skills 卡，把契约复审的路由直接改成 review 座位」
+  // and 「没有 fable 时，找 review 座位」; quoted in the body of card #33157, claim
+  // comment 6879512661): one line in the dispatch-prompt section — the order
+  // carries the route, the dev names the owed review in its hand-back and never
+  // knocks, the seat sends it to a review seat, never triage. Measured delta +1.
+  // Landed count, headroom 0, same convention.
+  ['.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/dispatch-runbook.md', 246],
   // Whole-text restructuring round (maintainer ruling 2026-08-23, Q1 = A):
   // mechanism detail extracted from SKILL.md — the four long state-table rows
   // (state-machine.md) and the clause-② review-chain operational detail
@@ -575,7 +582,16 @@ export const CEILINGS = new Map([
   // tails leave the corpus; one rule per ≤120-byte line, no rule already stated in
   // SKILL.md). Landed count, headroom 0, same convention (lowering is always
   // legitimate).
-  ['.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/contract-review.md', 60],
+  // Raised 60 → 63 by the contract-review route (maintainer, 2026-11-13, in the
+  // triage seat's session, verbatim: 「立 skills 卡，把契约复审的路由直接改成 review 座位」
+  // and 「没有 fable 时，找 review 座位」; quoted in the body of card #33157, claim
+  // comment 6879512661): the one routing rule — a lane self-reviews only when it
+  // reaches the tier; otherwise (unreachable, 429, rationed) it knocks a seated
+  // review seat, never triage, then a sibling seat with the tier, else the
+  // owed-review list — replaces the 429-only line (+2), and its one-line verbatim
+  // provenance carrying those two operative quotes (+1). Measured delta +3.
+  // Landed count, headroom 0, same convention.
+  ['.claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/contract-review.md', 63],
   // Business-perspective decision-analysis writing guide (maintainer ruling
   // 2026-08-20: the four-facet analysis must argue from the business
   // standpoint). Set at landed line count (headroom 0, same convention).

scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs

@@ -971,7 +971,8 @@ import { readClause2Line } from './clause2-line.mjs';
 import { CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER_NAME, TIER_DEFAULT, TIER_FLOOR, ceilingTierSpellings, containerModelRefusal } from './dispatch-gates.mjs';
 // The record's `Local-runs:` line is read by the file that owns the record's
 // every other line — judged when present, an absent line not re-judged.
-import { localRunsStand, readLocalRuns } from './record-recognisers.mjs';
+// The mailbox doorbell is read by the same file: a knock's `To:` seat and its key come from `readMailboxLine`.
+import { localRunsStand, readLocalRuns, readMailboxLine } from './record-recognisers.mjs';
 // The fleet's repository roster — the one place a repository joins the fleet —
 // is what a read-back may collapse a reference expansion against (header).
 import { GOVERNED_REPOS } from './check-governed-merges.mjs';
@@ -2510,6 +2511,36 @@ export function decisionFacetRefusalText(rows) {
   );
 }
 
+/**
+ * A contract-review knock addressed to triage — the route the rule text closes (`references/contract-review.md`
+ * 〈复核归属与资格〉): a lane that cannot take `CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER` sends `Request: contract-review` to a seated
+ * review seat, then to a sibling seat that can take the tier, else leaves the PR on the owed-review list — ⛔ never
+ * to triage. This is the write tool's input check on its own act, the same class as the signature and the keyed
+ * lines above it: no landing, check, workflow or queue reads it, and a knock it refuses was never on the board.
+ * The doorbell is read by its owner (`readMailboxLine`), never restated here. A knock it reads AND one it finds
+ * unreadable (no reason, a bare PR number, a second line) are both judged: an unreadable reading still carries the
+ * `id` and `to` parsed before the template failed, and a malformed knock to triage is still a knock to triage. A
+ * comment the reader refuses outright (no `To:` seat, a key outside the table) names no contract-review knock at
+ * all and passes, as it does today. Comments only. Answers the reading, or null. Pure.
+ */
+export function triageContractReviewKnock(body) {
+  const knock = readMailboxLine(String(body ?? ''));
+  if ((knock.state !== 'read' && knock.state !== 'unreadable') || knock.id !== 'request:contract-review') return null;
+  return /^triage#/u.test(knock.to) ? knock : null;
+}
+
+/** The refusal a caller reads, from `triageContractReviewKnock`'s reading. */
+export function triageContractReviewKnockText(knock) {
+  return (
+    `post-stamped: REFUSED — a \`Request: contract-review\` knock addressed to triage (\`To: ${knock.to}\`). Nothing was written.\n` +
+    '  A lane that cannot take CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER (the account cannot reach it, a 429 refusal, or the maintainer\n' +
+    '  rationed it) knocks a seated review seat\'s mailbox — `To: review#N`, the PR its seat post\'s `Mailbox:` line\n' +
+    '  names — and, while no review seat is seated, a sibling lane seat that can take the tier; with neither, the PR\n' +
+    '  waits on the owed-review list (`scripts/pm/check-owed-reviews.mjs`). ⛔ Never triage. The route is\n' +
+    '  `references/contract-review.md` 〈复核归属与资格〉. ⛔ No flag turns it off.'
+  );
+}
+
 /**
  * The block the platform appends to an artefact whose sent body does not
  * already carry one: a blank line, a rule, the bare attribution line — 58
@@ -3844,6 +3875,9 @@ export function judgeBody(input, options = {}, nowMs = Date.now(), tool = 'post-
   // ⛔ Comments only: a decision analysis is anchored on its card AS A COMMENT, and the handover check reads comments.
   const facets = options.mode === 'comment' ? decisionFacetRefusals(rendered.body) : [];
   if (facets.length > 0) return { ok: false, rendered, text: decisionFacetRefusalText(facets) };
+  // ⛔ Comments only: a mailbox knock IS a comment on the seat's mailbox PR.
+  const triageKnock = options.mode === 'comment' ? triageContractReviewKnock(rendered.body) : null;
+  if (triageKnock !== null) return { ok: false, rendered, text: triageContractReviewKnockText(triageKnock) };
   // ⛔ Bodies only: a VACANT seat post's ledger holds pointers, never obligations (#23396).
   const vacant = options.mode === 'body' ? vacantLedgerRefusals(rendered.body) : [];
   if (vacant.length > 0) return { ok: false, rendered, text: vacantLedgerRefusalText(vacant) };
@@ -3886,6 +3920,9 @@ const USAGE = [
   '  A comment that is a decision analysis — a decision frame, an options table or lettered options, and a',
   `  recommendation naming one — is REFUSED when it carries no \`${DECISION_FACET_MARKER}\` marker outside code; the`,
   '  refusal prints the four-facet block it owes. Card bodies and every other route are untouched.',
+  '  A mailbox comment whose `To:` is a triage seat and whose key is `Request: contract-review` is REFUSED, whether',
+  '  or not the key line spells its template: a lane without the review tier knocks a review seat, then a sibling',
+  '  seat with the tier — never triage.',
   '  The attribution footer is the caller\'s: its form differs by channel and act, so this tool adds none.',
   '',
   `  Exit: 0 written and stored · ${EXIT_USAGE} usage · ${EXIT_REFUSED} refused, nothing written ·`,
@@ -4117,6 +4154,7 @@ const SELF_TEST_BATTERIES = Object.freeze({
   "the size route: over the relay's body cap under auto THIS write goes direct with one line naming bytes, cap and identity; at or under it the relay; explicit dispatch refuses naming the bytes; nothing else re-routes": 13,
   'the signature: every body opens with LANE#N · ACCOUNT · SESSION or is refused, beside the stamp contract; one leading signature changes no reading': 11,
   'the one judge: every body refusal on ONE path — `main` and `label-write.mjs --comment-file` call `judgeBody`, never a copy': 8,
+  'the review route: a `Request: contract-review` knock addressed to triage is refused; to a review or sibling seat, and every other key to triage, it passes': 10,
 });
 const SELF_TEST_BATTERY_FLOOR = 18;
 const UNATTRIBUTED_BATTERY = '(unattributed)';
@@ -5656,6 +5694,26 @@ export function selfTest() {
     t('↔ structural: label-write imports judgeBody and judges its folded comment with it, ⛔ no reader of its own', /\bjudgeBody\b[^;]*from '\.\/post-stamped\.mjs'/u.test(lw) && /judgeBody\(text, \{ mode: 'comment' \}/u.test(lw) && !/function\s+(signatureRefusal|claimKeyedLineRefusals|decisionFacetRefusals)\b/u.test(lw));
   }
 
+  battery('the review route: a `Request: contract-review` knock addressed to triage is refused; to a review or sibling seat, and every other key to triage, it passes');
+  {
+    const SIG = 'domain:server#3 · os-bill · session_01QSeKYmhU5KEj1nukYhp1Tg';
+    const HEAD = '1b03a9c3d4e5f60718293a4b5c6d7e8f90a1b2c3';
+    const KNOCK = (to, key = `Request: contract-review · PR #26766 · head ${HEAD} · CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER rationed`) => `${SIG}\nTo: ${to}\n${key}`;
+    const judged = (to, key) => judgeBody(KNOCK(to, key), { mode: 'comment' }, NOW_MS);
+    const refused = judged('triage#1');
+    t('⭐ a contract-review knock addressed to `triage#1` is refused, and the refusal names the seat it was addressed to', !refused.ok && refused.text.startsWith('post-stamped: REFUSED') && refused.text.includes('`To: triage#1`'));
+    t('⭐ …and the refusal names the review seat\'s mailbox, the sibling fallback, the owed-review list and the rule\'s home', refused.text.includes('`To: review#N`') && refused.text.includes('`Mailbox:`') && refused.text.includes('sibling lane seat') && refused.text.includes('check-owed-reviews.mjs') && refused.text.includes('references/contract-review.md') && refused.text.includes('Nothing was written'));
+    t('⭐ a MALFORMED knock to triage is refused too — no reason, a bare PR number, a second line: the reader\'s unreadable reading still names the key and the seat', [`Request: contract-review · PR #26766 · head ${HEAD}`, 'Request: contract-review · 26766 · rationed', `Request: contract-review · PR #26766 · head ${HEAD} · rationed\nbecause fable is short today`].every((key) => { const r = judged('triage#1', key); return !r.ok && r.text.includes('`To: triage#1`'); }) && judged('review#1', `Request: contract-review · PR #26766 · head ${HEAD}`).ok);
+    t('a bare `To: triage` reads as `triage#1` (the doorbell reader\'s seat spelling) and is refused the same way', !judged('triage').ok && !judged('Triage#2').ok);
+    t('⭐ the same knock addressed to a review seat passes', judged('review#1').ok && judged('review#2').ok);
+    t('…and to a sibling lane seat, the fallback while no review seat is seated', judged('domain:server#2').ok);
+    t('⛔ every other key to triage is untouched: `Request: urgent-triage` and `Request: triage` pass', judged('triage#1', 'Request: urgent-triage · #26766 · main red on Test Core').ok && judged('triage#1', 'Request: triage · #26766 · which lane takes it').ok);
+    t('⛔ a card BODY is untouched — the check is a comment\'s, as a knock is a comment on a mailbox PR', judgeBody(KNOCK('triage#1'), { mode: 'body' }, NOW_MS).ok);
+    t('⛔ the refusal\'s own words (the seat it echoes aside) carry no tracker number and no HTML comment — a runtime string an author is shown', /#\d/u.test(triageContractReviewKnockText({ to: 'SEAT' })) === false && triageContractReviewKnockText({ to: 'SEAT' }).includes('<!--') === false);
+    const own = readFileSync(SELF_PATH, 'utf8');
+    t('structural: the doorbell reader is imported from the file that owns it, ⛔ never restated, and the check runs inside judgeBody on comments only', /import \{[^}]*\breadMailboxLine\b[^}]*\} from '\.\/record-recognisers\.mjs';/u.test(own) && !/function\s+readMailboxLine\b/u.test(own) && /const triageKnock = options\.mode === 'comment' \? triageContractReviewKnock\(rendered\.body\) : null;/u.test(own));
+  }
+
   // The floor, evaluated last: a battery that stops running names itself here.
   const failed = cases.filter((c) => !c.ok);
   for (const c of cases) console.log(`  ${c.ok ? '✓' : '✗'} ${c.name}`);